Inspection visits to Tesla employees on sick leave

Due to an unusually high number of sick days at the German Tesla factory, Managing Director André Thierig and Head of Human Resources Erik Demmler visited employees unannounced at home. They were not amused.

Image: Tesla

According to the Handelsblatt, Thierig and Demmler spoke at a works meeting, of which the German newspaper has an audio recording. In August, the level of sick leave among the 12,000 employees in Grünheide had risen to 17 per cent, and at the beginning of September, it was still at 11 per cent. That is apparently not acceptable.

“That meant we had to go to the people. And that’s what we did. This has nothing to do with general suspicion. We simply picked out 30 employees who had the relevant abnormalities, who had been on sick leave for quite a long time, but also to a lot of people who handed in first sick notes,” Demmler is quoted as saying.

The unannounced inspection visits by top managers were obviously not well received. “You could just tell by the aggression,” Demmler continues. “By having the door slammed shut. By being threatened with the police. By being asked if you don’t have to make an appointment first.”

Demmler obviously emphasised that the intention was not to criticise or make demands of the employees – rather, they wanted to find out how people were doing and how they could help. However, the conflict is not new. As early as 2023, Thierig criticised the attitude of some employees. There was no room in his factory for people who “couldn’t get out of bed” in the morning, he said at a works meeting. In July 2024, Tesla even offered a bonus for employees with low sick leave.

It remains to be seen whether the controversial home visits will help to reduce the number of sick employees. From a legal perspective, however, they are probably justifiable, as unannounced home visits by the employer are not prohibited – “at least if the employer suspects that something is wrong with the sick note.”

handelsblatt.com (in German)

31 Comments

about „Inspection visits to Tesla employees on sick leave“
Gary Anthony Tulie
26.09.2024 um 07:47
In the UK such visits are prohibited, as is asking the sick person for details of their sickness - (patient confidentiality). What the employer can do is get occupational health involved to work with individuals to plan for their return to work, and to work out what if any adjustments might be needed to facilitate their return be it phased return at reduced hours, physical modifications like standing desks, or improved accessibility, or changes to job description and responsibilities either temporary or permanent. The occupational health person is an independent professional hired as a consultant and not employed by the firm and acts as an intermediary so that whilst they might be granted access to medical records, the employer is not!
Larkin
27.09.2024 um 04:25
In the UK, the state employee doctors are known to write sick notes for anyone for any reason, no sickness necessary .People used to ask me why I was taking a vacation day for 1 day, as I should just get a note from the Dr and take the free paid day off. Getting things done there is tough, people act offended they have to help you.
Mark Scott
27.09.2024 um 11:05
That is complete BS. You clearly have no knowledge or experience of the UK healthcare system other than what you've read or heard from unreliable sources. Doctors in UK are not state employees - most are either partners in a privately owned medical practice, otherwise employees of such a practice. Practices are paid by the state based on how many patients are registered with them.
Rob
26.09.2024 um 09:28
I worked in Austria 35 years ago. At the time, if you were ill, you were expected to go to the doctor and get a note. As well, one was expected to stay at home a minimum of 3 days, in order to not spread illness at work. And, one could be visited by a nurse to check on you during that time, because one was expected to be at home resting.So, perhaps these inspections are permitted by German law. If they weren't, I would assume that the company would get in to trouble.
Fengo
27.09.2024 um 06:26
Are these managers qualified nurses then?
Andre
26.09.2024 um 10:29
If you are sick, you can not work well, however if you pretend, to be sick... Not right at all, In Asia work is sacred,..it is against you, and respect for work.. In western world more benefits, les productivity, rise in Inflation.. Resect the one that, are giving you the money..If you do not like it, go some where.
pj cremin
26.09.2024 um 21:40
And that's why companies think they can do anything like prying into people's private lives, off the clock, when there's brown noses like you, ready to kill yourself for a job where you could and would be replaced if you died. Get a life Andre
William
26.09.2024 um 11:43
Maybe it was just general concern .. what if there was something wrong with the work place and the bosses wanted to find out if they were in the same place or working on the same machines .. possibly some emitting radiation .. then the bosses are good guys for their concern..
Fengo
27.09.2024 um 06:17
A phone call us all it would take and by HR not the managwrs. Turning up unannounced is the problem. What if your illness embarrassing? Are you the supposed to explain this to an upper manager on your doorstep? Not in your house of course as they have no right to enter. What if it was very contagious? Now the managers will bring it back to work with them causing more sick leave, more home visits, more contangion, more sick leave etc.
Bud
27.09.2024 um 02:20
If they had good intentions, they clearly would have called first and not just shown up.
David William Moore
26.09.2024 um 22:45
They're making cars William, not nukes.
Brigitta S.
26.09.2024 um 19:33
They could have simply made a phone call
Nico
26.09.2024 um 17:45
Regardless of whether or not those visited have something to hide, I think most people would regard Tesla's approach to organizing these visits ham-fisted and naive. This is a poor reflection on the Tesla management with respect to management-employee relationships.
Shoeshoe
26.09.2024 um 20:07
The employer has a duty to visit an employee at home who have been away on sick leave. In terms of our Basic Conditions of Employment Act. Information providing the details of an employee is a statutory requirement for purposes of situation like this and where the employer wishes to serve a notice to an employee. In South Afrrica, if an employee is not at work for a long time or there is a pattern of absenteeism is established the employer must show that they tried to locate an employee . This is a requirement to prove your case at arbitration that they made efforts to locate the employee before implementing the deeming provision that the employee does not intend coming to work.
Derek Spaeth
26.09.2024 um 21:01
It is one thing to send a text asking how they are feeling. But the unannounced visit in person is on another level. Who arrives anywhere nowadays unannounced? It is bad manners and it makes it clear their true intention is to catch people lying.
LUKE TUCCILLO
26.09.2024 um 22:28
If all these people were really sick and worked close to each other I would think the company should be concerned and checking on them is no big deal, unless they aren't really sick.
Blake
26.09.2024 um 22:48
Sick leave is a benefit given to an employee when they are hired to the organization. If the organization has a problem with people calling out sick and using the time that they have given them, than they should change their policies and give the absolute minimum that's required by law. How an employee uses that time is up to him or her and the fault remains on them if they run out of it when they really need it. I don't see how it's a problem when the employer should expect the time that is given to their employees is to be used.
Bone
26.09.2024 um 23:03
If you aren't faking being sick, then you really shouldn't be upset or concerned.
ProudAmerican
26.09.2024 um 23:34
Pathetic. Whatever happened to work ethic in Germany?
Gwenie
26.09.2024 um 23:40
There is another version which is your right. Here a vacation leave must be applied weeks ahead. If for some reason on that day you had to go on leave we generally do sick leave cos its a sudden thing n cnt be called vacation leave. Forr sick leave if less than 5 days no need for medical leave . Sick can be rest n outpatient You are entitled to a x day of leave sick n x day of leave vacation n in a yeae its a right so you can hv that total leave however u need it.
David Reilly
27.09.2024 um 00:13
Complete invasion of privacy
ahe
27.09.2024 um 00:28
Check out Australia's Newly Recent Workforce implemented legislation named "Right To Disconnect "
Sean
27.09.2024 um 00:43
Wow the corporate shills in the comment section. This is an invasion of privacy. Tesla don't own their workers. They can call or email, if no response then the company can issue warnings or take further action but showing up at your doorstep? Nope , no way!
David Brown
27.09.2024 um 00:49
In California, US, after 2 days off sick, you have to have a doctor note to come back.
Lbd
27.09.2024 um 01:18
What a load. Everyone knows Elon musk. “working ethic”. You work until you drop. Of course you can’t drop at home, you have to be at work. You should be sleeping there too. Who needs a home or family when your life should be work? Unfortunately for him this is Germany. The country that promotes work life balance. Maybe if Mr Musk would spend an hour a day with each one of his offspring he would understand more about life ,work, family balance. His workers are not slaves. They aren’t profit sharing his billions
Made
27.09.2024 um 02:48
"In my opinion, it's normal for a company representative to visit an employee who has been on extended sick leave. They can assess if there's any support they can offer, such as assistance with medical expenses, to help the employee return to work sooner. It’s a win-win approach, unless the employee is trying to take advantage of the situation, like avoiding work while still receiving benefits. This was my experience with one of the largest automotive companies from Asia."
L
27.09.2024 um 02:54
Companies need to understand whats wrong with the work place in my opinion. Then get others who are unemployed in if its suspect.
Raakhee
27.09.2024 um 03:19
This sounds like it seems! I don’t think the top officials out of the goodness of their heart went to these employees homes! And that is ridiculous! There is definitely a way to bring employees back to work after being sick. What is ur company policy? How long is long enough?Plus mental health at this place seems non-existent. I really didn’t think working at Tesla or for Elon Musk was so bad. I was having an argument with my friend who told me that is the case and now I am finding many such results. So sad.
Jason
27.09.2024 um 08:05
They're not caring for them, they are just inspecting. Don't need to be a nurse to. If someone is obviously sick lol
Petrus Nortje
27.09.2024 um 09:48
Let me tell u all High sick notes mean there is a shitty atmosfere at work Bosses are pressing the people to the last drop They dont listen to sugestions and paperwork is like getting out of hand I know i was there If work en iroment is friendly and open no bullshit and fair people will run to work If bonusses dont even work u know place is not good
Kyle
27.09.2024 um 10:29
I had an ex boss show up at my house unannounced the first day I called in sick. Unluckily for him I had moved a month before, but I forgot to give him my new address. I'll never for the call he made when he thought he had "busted" me for not being at home. He was so pleased with himself, in his mind he had caught me lying. Then the moment I explained he was not at the right house, the mood changed instantly. I couldn't help but laugh at him. Needless to say I found another job not long after that.